Showing posts with label Specialized. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Specialized. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 22, 2010

Been Doing Some Reading

"The AIDS Memorial Quilt and the Contemporary Culture of Commemoration" - Carole Blair and Neil Michel

Explores the issue of public vs. private commemoration (especially in terms of government sanctioned and grass-roots supported memorials). The most interesting and most important for me in this article is Blair and Michel's discussion of how the AIDS quilt and the VVM are multimodal memorials that invite audiences (users) to interact with the memorial itself. The AIDS quilt has panels that are made with various materials and often not made by family members or those one would think would be responsible for doing the memorial. The VVM, although linear and simply lists names, visitors often leave momentos behind that are for commemoration. This allows those if grief more agency in commemorating those they have lost.

"Transcendance at Yellowstone Educating a Public in an Uninhabitable Place" - Gregory Clark
Clark discusses the educational possibilities of a "public experience," much like visiting a national park. What makes this interesting is the discussion of a collective public experience. People from all over the world, with varying backgrounds and experience come together to experience the same thing, but obviously in different ways. Coming together actually allows people to move past their differences.

Sunday, September 12, 2010

Specialized Question

I haven't technically been given the go-ahead for three of my four questions (the ones from a large list of questions we have to choose from and revise accordingly), but they appear to be heading in the right direction. My fourth, specialized question was given the very polite comment of,

"There's a lot going on in here."

(Between the lines, I heard, "Wow, uh...wow!")

So, after some discussion with my chair and the fact that I told my comps class I would come with a question to workshop this Wednesday, I went back to the drawing board, figured out what I actually want to say in my response and crafted another question. Here is what I came up with:

Donavon J. Ochs argues, “Rituals of consolation, filled as they are with symbols, used rhetorically, need to be viewed as attempts to persuade. The incredibly heterogeneous nature of those who attend and participate in funeral rituals require more than a eulogy can be expected, realistically, to provide in addressing their individual and collective emotional and cognitive concerns (13).” Considering this argument and the work of others (Blair, Trimbur) in regards to the rhetoric of commemoration and memorial, how are these rhetorical approaches shifting as multimodality is changing the shape of how people commemorate those they have lost?

I don't know why I get so nervous at the thought of sharing this with my peers. But I am. I always, always always feel (and may never quite get over it) that people are like, "How did she get in here." Even now, starting my third year, I get those jitters.

And yet, I am sharing it here for the whole world to see. Weird.

If anyone out there comes upon this and would like to offer up some suggestions - and you can be honest, nice but honest, if I am totally fully of shit.

(I may change the name of this blog to, "Tell Me if I Am Full of Shit: The Life of a Grad Student in Flux During Comprehensive Exams."